CONVERSIONS
Changing Entity Type in the Middle of an Operating Year
You can usually change now: what it costs depends on direction, on three fixed statutory deadlines, and on a license or consent nobody put on the calendar
It is June and somebody has told you that you are in the wrong structure. The
question you want answered is whether you can change now or whether you have to
wait until January. The honest answer is that you can usually change now, and
that the cost of doing it in June rather than in January is mostly paperwork
rather than tax, except in a few directions where it is the opposite.
Before anything else, be specific about which change is meant, because four
different things get called changing the entity and they have almost nothing in
common.
A tax election. The legal entity stays exactly what it is. You file a form
and the IRS treats it differently. An LLC electing to be taxed as a corporation,
or a corporation electing subchapter S, or an S corporation dropping back to C.
Nothing about the state filing changes.
A statutory conversion. One filing with the state turns an LLC into a
corporation or the reverse. Most states allow it. The entity is treated as
continuing, which means contracts, property titles and the entity's history
generally carry over without a transfer.
A merger. You form the new entity and merge the old one into it. Used where
conversion is unavailable or where you are also changing states. The surviving
entity takes the assets and the liabilities by operation of law.
Form, transfer, dissolve. The old way. Create the new company, move the
assets by deed and bill of sale, assign the contracts, wind down the old one.
Most expensive, most moving parts, and occasionally the only route.
The calendar rules that are genuinely fixed
Three timing rules come from statute or regulation rather than from anyone's
preference. Those are the ones to plan around.
The S election deadline. Under Section 1362, Form 2553 is filed no more than two
months and fifteen days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to
take effect, or at any time during the preceding tax year. File later than that
and the election normally takes effect the following year. The IRS publishes a
relief procedure for late elections with conditions attached, and it is used
often, but it is relief rather than a second deadline.
The five year lockout on classification changes. Under the entity classification
regulations, once a business entity elects its classification, it generally
cannot elect again for sixty months. There are exceptions, including one for an
election made effective on the date the entity was formed. Owners who flip
because of a bad year are usually surprised by this one.
The five year wait after terminating an S election. Under Section 1362, a
corporation whose S election terminated or was revoked generally may not elect
again for five tax years without the consent of the IRS. Revoking S status to
retain earnings at corporate rates is a decision with a long tail.
There is one more rule that is fixed but not a calendar rule, and it deserves the
same weight. A C corporation that converts to S status carries a built-in gains
exposure under Section 1374 on appreciation that existed at the conversion date,
for a recognition period of five years. Sell an appreciated asset inside that
window and the corporation pays tax at the corporate level on the built-in gain.
A company on LIFO inventory also faces a recapture amount on the way in.
One direction is cheap and the other is expensive
This is the part that determines whether a mid-year change is a small project or
a large one, and it has nothing to do with the month.
Going from a pass-through to a corporation is usually a tax-free step. A
contribution of assets to a corporation in exchange for its stock qualifies for
nonrecognition under Section 351 when the contributors control the corporation
afterward. That is the mechanism behind converting an LLC taxed as a partnership
into a corporation, and it is why owners are told the change is painless.
It has an edge that catches a business carrying debt. Under Section 357, if the
liabilities transferred exceed the basis of the assets transferred, the excess is
gain and you recognize it. A company carrying depreciated equipment against a
loan balance can be in exactly that position without knowing it. Model this
before you file, particularly if there is significant equipment debt.
Going the other way is where the expensive surprise lives. A corporation that
converts to an LLC taxed as a partnership is generally treated as liquidating.
For a C corporation, that means gain is recognized at the corporate level on the
appreciation in its assets and again at the shareholder level on the distribution.
Two layers of tax on a change many owners assume is a filing. Getting out of a
corporation is usually harder and costlier than getting into one, and that
asymmetry is the strongest argument for thinking carefully before you get in.
A mid-year change also splits your tax year. If an LLC taxed as a partnership
becomes a corporation in June, you file a final partnership return for the part
of the year before the change and a corporate return for the part after. That is
two return preparation fees in one year and two sets of allocations. It is a real
cost and it is a known one.
What breaks outside the tax return
The tax analysis gets the attention. The list below is what actually consumes the
weeks, and it is the same list every time.
- The employer identification number. Some changes require a new one and some
do not. The IRS publishes the rules by scenario. A corporation electing S
status keeps its number. An LLC that becomes a corporation frequently needs a
new one. Assume nothing here.
- Payroll. Changing employers mid-year raises the question of whether wages
already paid count toward the annual Social Security wage base, or whether the
base restarts and you pay twice on the same wages. There is a published
predecessor and successor procedure that addresses this. Tell your payroll
provider before the change, not after.
- The bank. New signature card, new resolution, and in some cases a new
account entirely. Every automatic payment and deposit tied to the old account
has to be redirected.
- Loan documents. Many notes and lines require lender consent before a change
in organizational form, and some treat it as a default. Read the covenants
first, then ask. Consent is usually given and is rarely given retroactively.
- Security interests on file. A lender's UCC filing names a debtor. Change
the debtor's name or form and that filing may need an amendment to stay
effective. Your lender will care about this even if you do not.
- Licenses and permits. Trade licenses, sales tax permits, liquor licenses,
professional registrations and contractor bonds are all issued to a named
entity. Some transfer, some require a fresh application with a waiting period.
A license with a long re-issue time can set the date for the whole project.
- Contracts. Assignment clauses and change of control clauses in customer
agreements, leases and franchise documents can require consent. A statutory
conversion avoids many of these because the entity continues, which is one of
the better arguments for conversion over form-and-transfer.
- Insurance. Policies are issued to a named insured. A claim against an
entity that is not the named insured is an argument you do not want.
- Real property. If title moves, expect transfer tax, possible reassessment,
and a due on sale clause on any mortgage.
Choosing the date
Default to a year boundary unless something specific argues against it. The split
returns, the split payroll and the double set of registrations all disappear if
the change lines up with your tax year, and the savings you were chasing rarely
turn on eight months instead of twelve.
Argue against it when the numbers are large enough that eight months of payroll
tax saving exceeds the cost of the split, when a sale or a financing is driving
the date, or when a lender or licensing body has set the date for you.
Then work backward from the longest lead item. That is almost never the tax
filing. It is a license re-issue, a lender consent, or a landlord's signature,
and it is the thing that will decide when this actually happens.
Common questions
can i change from an llc to an s corp mid year
The S election has a statutory deadline: no more than two months and fifteen days after the start of the tax year it should apply to, or any time in the preceding year. Whether a mid-year effective date works depends on when your entity's tax year begins for this purpose, so have it modeled before filing. The IRS also publishes a relief procedure for late elections with conditions you must meet.
is it expensive to change entity type
It depends entirely on direction. Moving from a pass-through into a corporation is usually a nonrecognition event, subject to a rule that creates gain when transferred liabilities exceed the basis of transferred assets. Moving a corporation back out is generally treated as a liquidation and can be taxed at both the corporate and the owner level.
do i need a new ein if i change my entity type
Sometimes. A corporation electing S status keeps its existing number, while an LLC that becomes a corporation often needs a new one. The IRS publishes the answer by scenario, so check yours rather than assuming, because the number flows into payroll, the bank and every vendor form you have on file.