RECORDS
Corporate Minutes, and Why a Lender Asks to See Them
The request is not about meetings: it is proof that the person signing can bind the company, and it runs as a chain from the statute to the signature
Two weeks before closing, the lender's checklist comes back with a line on it
that reads "corporate minutes and resolutions." You have never kept minutes. You
are one owner, or two, and the idea of holding a meeting with yourself seems
absurd. The request feels like a formality invented to slow you down.
It is not a formality, and it is not really about meetings. What the lender is
buying with that line is proof of authority. They are about to hand money to a
company on the strength of a signature, and before they do it they want an
unbroken chain showing that the person signing has the power to bind the entity
and that the entity has the power to do the thing. If any link in that chain is
missing, their closing attorney cannot give a clean opinion, and a closing
attorney who cannot give a clean opinion does not fund.
The lender is buying a chain of authority
The chain runs in a fixed order, and every document on the checklist occupies one
position in it.
The statute permits an entity of this type to borrow money and grant security.
The articles or certificate of formation, on file with the state, created this
entity and did not restrict that power. The bylaws or the operating agreement
say who inside the company may exercise it and under what vote. A resolution,
adopted by the people the governing document names, authorizes this specific
transaction, in this amount, with this counterparty, and names the person who may
sign. An incumbency certificate confirms that the person named still holds the
office and that the signature on the certificate matches. A certificate of good
standing confirms the entity currently exists in the eyes of the state.
Each link answers a question the one above it cannot. That is why substituting a
general statement will not work. An operating agreement saying the manager may
borrow tells the lender the category is permitted. It does not tell them the
members approved this loan.
The reason the lender cares after closing is the part owners do not see. If the
company later stops paying and argues that the person who signed had no authority
to sign, the resolution is the document that ends the argument. An institution
that lends without it is choosing to litigate that question someday. They would
rather not.
What the file actually contains at a closing
The exact list varies, and the contents are consistent.
- A certified or file-stamped copy of the articles or certificate of formation,
plus any amendments.
- The current bylaws or operating agreement, with amendments, certified by an
officer or manager as complete and in effect.
- A resolution or written consent authorizing the transaction, adopted by
whoever the governing document says must adopt it.
- An incumbency certificate listing current officers or managers with specimen
signatures.
- A certificate of good standing from the formation state, usually dated within
a specified window, and one from each state where the entity is qualified.
- For a bank account, a separate banking resolution on the bank's own form
naming authorized signers.
Two practical notes on that list. Good standing certificates expire for this
purpose, so pull them late rather than early. And the operating agreement being
certified as current is where a lot of files stall, because the version in the
drawer does not reflect the ownership change from two years ago that everyone
agreed to verbally.
What goes in minutes and what does not
Minutes are a record of a decision. They are not a transcript, and length is not
a virtue here. A useful set of minutes or a written consent contains the date,
who participated, confirmation that the required vote or quorum existed, a plain
statement of what was decided, how each person voted if it was not unanimous,
and any conflict of interest that was disclosed along with how it was handled.
That conflict line matters more than its size suggests. When the company leases
a building from its own owner, buys from a second company the owner controls, or
sets the owner's compensation, the decision is an interested transaction. Most
state statutes give you a path to make it binding anyway, usually by disclosing
the interest and having it approved by the disinterested parties. The record of
that disclosure is the defense later, and there is no way to reconstruct it
honestly after the fact.
Here is the set of acts worth documenting in an ordinary year. Opening or
closing a bank account. Borrowing, or granting a security interest in company
assets. Signing a lease. Buying or selling real property. Admitting an owner or
issuing additional ownership interests. Setting officer or owner compensation.
Declaring a distribution. Entering into any transaction with an owner or an
affiliated company. Adopting or changing a tax election. Selling substantially
all of the assets. Dissolving.
What does not need minutes is the running of the business. Hiring a second
driver, choosing a supplier, signing a routine customer contract. If everything
gets a resolution, the file becomes noise and nobody keeps it up.
Meetings you do not actually have to hold
Corporation statutes generally require an annual shareholders meeting and
contemplate regular director meetings. Nearly every state also allows action by
unanimous written consent in place of a meeting, which is what small companies
actually use. A one page document titled "Action by Written Consent of the Sole
Shareholder," stating the decision and signed and dated, satisfies the
requirement without anyone sitting in a room.
LLCs are different again. Most LLC acts impose no meeting requirement at all, and
many say explicitly that failing to observe formalities is not a ground for
imposing personal liability on a member. So the veil piercing argument for
keeping LLC minutes is weaker than it is usually sold. The reasons that survive
are the ones in this article: lenders ask, buyers ask, and an interested
transaction needs a record. Your own operating agreement may also require member
consent for certain acts, and if it does, that requirement is enforceable against
you whatever the statute says.
Fixing a gap without backdating
Most owners reading this have a gap. Several years of decisions with nothing
written down. The instinct is to sit down with a stack of paper and date each
document to the year the decision was made.
Do not. A document signed today that states it was adopted three years ago is a
false statement in a file that a lender, a buyer or a court will read, and the
problem it creates is worse than the gap it covers. It is also easy to detect.
The clean mechanism is ratification. Prepare a consent dated today which recites
the prior actions and ratifies, confirms and approves them as of today, by the
people who have authority to do that now. It reads honestly, it makes the record
complete going forward, and nobody has to pretend. If some of those actions
required a vote that was never taken, that is a real issue and it should be
addressed rather than papered.
Then change the habit. One folder, digital is fine, one page per decision, signed
and dated on the day. It takes ten minutes a year for most small companies. And
it means the next time a checklist asks for minutes, you send a file instead of
spending closing week reconstructing three years of your own history.
Common questions
why does a lender want to see corporate minutes
They are verifying authority: that the entity is permitted to borrow, that the people inside it approved this specific loan, and that the person signing holds the office they claim. The resolution is what ends any later argument that the signer lacked power to bind the company. Without it the closing attorney cannot deliver a clean authority opinion.
does an llc have to keep minutes
Most LLC statutes impose no meeting requirement, and many state that failing to observe formalities is not a ground for personal liability. Your operating agreement can still require member consent for specific acts, and that requirement binds you. Lenders and buyers will ask for written consents regardless of what the statute requires.
can i write up minutes for past years
Do not date a document to a year it was not signed in, because that is a false record in a file outsiders will read. Use a consent dated today that recites the earlier actions and ratifies them as of today. It completes the record honestly and is accepted for the purpose it needs to serve.