ENTITY CHOICE
LLC, S Corp, or C Corp: The Differences That Actually Cost You Money
Two of these three are tax elections, not entities: what each one changes about your payroll, your ownership options and the debt on your books
You form an LLC. You do not form an S corporation. That one sentence is most of
the confusion, and the confusion costs owners real money every filing season.
An LLC is a creature of state law. You file articles of organization with a
secretary of state, you pay the fee, and the state recognizes a company that is
legally separate from the person who owns it. A corporation works the same way
with different paperwork and a different vocabulary. Those two are the entities.
"S corporation" and "C corporation" are not entities at all. They are subchapters
of the federal tax code, and they describe how the IRS treats a business that
already exists. A corporation is taxed under subchapter C unless it elects out.
An LLC can file Form 2553 and be taxed under subchapter S while staying an LLC in
every other respect: same articles, same operating agreement, same name on the
lease, same registered agent.
So there are two questions here, not one. Which entity do you form under state
law, and which tax treatment do you elect for it. Owners answer them as a single
question and then wonder why their lawyer and their accountant appear to be
describing different companies.
What the self-employment tax argument actually is
Almost every "you should be an S corp" conversation is about one thing. It is
about the 15.3 percent that funds Social Security and Medicare, and about which
slice of your profit it touches.
If you run a single member LLC with no election, the IRS disregards the company
for income tax. Your profit lands on Schedule C, and self-employment tax applies
to 92.35 percent of net earnings from the business. The Social Security half
stops at an annual wage base that Congress adjusts every year. The Medicare half
does not stop.
If the same company elects S treatment, you become an employee of your own
business. You run payroll, you take a salary that is subject to the usual
withholding, and the profit left over after that salary is a distribution. The
distribution is not subject to self-employment tax. That gap is the entire pitch.
Take a shop with 90,000 dollars of profit after every expense except the owner's
pay. As a disregarded LLC, self-employment tax applies to 83,115 dollars, which
is 92.35 percent of the profit. At 15.3 percent that is about 12,716 dollars.
Now say the same owner elects S treatment and sets a salary of 55,000 dollars.
Payroll taxes on that salary run about 8,415 dollars, half withheld from the
owner and half paid by the company out of the same pot of money. The remaining
profit comes out as a distribution and carries no payroll tax. The difference is
roughly 4,300 dollars.
That number is a hypothetical I am computing with, not a promise. Against it you
have to set a separate federal return on Form 1120-S, a payroll service,
quarterly employment filings, W-2s, and whatever your state charges an S
corporation that it would not have charged an LLC. Some states impose an
entity-level tax or a gross-receipts fee that pays no attention to the federal
election at all. Ask what your state does before you run the arithmetic, because
the answer changes the arithmetic.
And the salary number is not yours to choose freely. The standard is reasonable
compensation for the work you actually perform, and it is enforced. The IRS
examines it, and courts have recharacterized distributions as wages when the
salary an owner set was too small to be credible for the job that owner was
doing. A salary of nothing, in a company where you are the only person producing
the revenue, is the audit that finds itself.
The eligibility rules that end the conversation early
Subchapter S is a narrow door. The requirements sit in Section 1361 of the
Internal Revenue Code, and they are not negotiable.
- No more than 100 shareholders, with family members countable as one.
- Shareholders must be individuals, estates, or certain qualifying trusts.
A partnership cannot hold the stock. Another corporation cannot hold it,
except in the specific parent-subsidiary case the code allows.
- No nonresident alien shareholders.
- One class of stock. Differences in voting rights are fine. Differences in
rights to profit and liquidation proceeds are not.
That last one ends more deals than the rest combined. If you plan to bring in a
partner on a preferred return, or issue an interest that gets paid back first,
you have created a second economic class and the election is gone. An LLC taxed
as a partnership handles that structure without blinking. So if your growth plan
involves anything other than everybody sharing profit strictly in proportion to
ownership, the S election is a fence you will hit.
Where the C corporation is the right answer
A C corporation pays tax on its own income at a flat federal rate of 21 percent
under Section 11, and then the owners pay again on dividends when money comes
out. That is the double tax everyone warns about, and for a business whose
owners need to pull out most of the profit every year, the warning is correct.
It stops being correct in two situations.
The first is capital. Venture funds and most institutional investors cannot hold
S corporation stock, because a partnership is not an eligible shareholder. They
also do not want a K-1 from your operating business landing in their partners'
tax returns. If you are raising that kind of money, you will be converted to a
C corporation before the wire arrives, and the only question is whether you pay
to do it under time pressure. Section 1202 stock, the qualified small business
stock rules, also requires C corporation stock issued by a C corporation.
The second is retention. If the business genuinely reinvests profit rather than
distributing it, the 21 percent rate on retained earnings can beat individual
rates on pass-through income that you never actually receive. There are limits.
The accumulated earnings tax exists precisely to stop a corporation from hoarding
profit to dodge shareholder-level tax, so the retention has to be tied to the
needs of the business.
Debt, basis, and the thing that surprises people in year three
Here is the difference nobody mentions at formation, and it matters most to the
kind of business that borrows.
In a partnership, and that includes a multi-member LLC with no election, a
member's basis includes a share of the company's liabilities. Basis is the
ceiling on the losses you can deduct. A partnership that borrows to buy equipment
pushes basis up for its members, and an early-year loss flows through and is
usable.
Subchapter S does not work that way. An S corporation shareholder gets basis from
contributed cash and property and from loans the shareholder personally makes to
the corporation. A bank loan sitting on the company's books gives the shareholder
nothing, even with a personal guarantee. Guaranteeing the debt is not lending the
money. So the same business, financed the same way, can produce a deductible loss
in one structure and a suspended loss in the other.
The owners who feel this are the ones who started with an LLC, elected S
treatment to save payroll tax, then took on equipment debt and posted a loss year.
The loss suspends. It carries forward, and it will be usable when basis appears,
but it is not usable in the year the cash left.
How to actually decide
Work in this order.
- Form the entity that fits your ownership plan and your state. For most
operating businesses with one to a few owners, that is an LLC.
- Decide the tax treatment separately, with a projection of at least a full
year of real numbers in front of you.
- Check the S eligibility rules against who will own this in three years, not
who owns it today.
- Price the compliance cost of payroll and a second return against the payroll
tax saving, in dollars, for your own profit level.
- Ask what your state charges under each treatment, because the federal answer
is only part of the bill.
If the profit is small, the S election costs more than it saves. If the profit is
substantial and stable and you are the person generating it, it usually pays. If
you are raising institutional money, the question was never open. What you should
not do is pick a structure because a video told you to, and then find out in
February which of these rules you tripped.
Common questions
can an llc be taxed as an s corp
Yes. An LLC that meets the Section 1361 eligibility rules can file Form 2553 and be taxed under subchapter S without changing its legal form. It stays an LLC for every state-law purpose, including its articles and its operating agreement. Only the federal tax treatment changes, and your state may or may not follow.
when is it worth electing s corp status
The saving comes from the payroll tax you avoid on distributions, so it scales with profit above a reasonable salary. Against that saving you pay for payroll processing, a separate federal return, and any state tax that applies to an S corporation. Run the arithmetic on your own projected profit before you file anything.
what is the deadline to file form 2553
Under Section 1362, the election is filed no more than two months and fifteen days after the start of the tax year it should take effect in, or at any time during the preceding tax year. Missing that window normally pushes the election to the following year. The IRS has a published relief procedure for late elections, and it has conditions you have to meet.