Entity Order Structure, governance, and the paperwork that holds.

Entity Order

GOVERNING DOCUMENTS

What an Operating Agreement Must Say, and What Your Template Left Out

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

Where your agreement is silent, your state's statute decides for you: the clauses that fail first are about money out, signing authority and getting out

Somebody told you the LLC needs an operating agreement, you downloaded one,

everybody signed it, and it went in a drawer. The question you are actually

asking is whether that document would do anything if the business got into

trouble. For most of the agreements I read, the answer is that it would do very

little, because the clauses that matter under pressure are the ones the template

left out.

An operating agreement is a contract among the owners about how the company is

run and how money moves. It is not a filing. The state does not read it, does not

keep it, and in most states does not require it. What the state does keep is a

statute, and that statute is full of default rules that apply to your company

whenever your agreement is silent. Silence is not the absence of a rule. Silence

means the legislature picks for you, and the legislature wrote those defaults for

a generic company, not yours.

The agreement is a contract against the state's defaults

Read your state's LLC act and you will find the phrase "unless the operating

agreement provides otherwise" over and over. That phrase is the whole point. Each

appearance is a decision the statute is willing to let you make, and a decision

it will make for you if you do not.

Some of those defaults are fine. Some are the opposite of what the owners assume.

A common one: in a number of states, if the agreement says nothing about voting,

each member gets one vote regardless of how much money they put in. The owner who

funded 80 percent of the business and the owner who funded 20 percent each have a

single vote, and the minority owner holds a veto nobody agreed to give them.

Another: in many acts, profits and losses are allocated in proportion to capital

contributions unless you say otherwise, which is not what most working partners

intend when one brings cash and the other brings the trade.

So the first job of a real agreement is not to invent a governance system. It is

to walk the statute's list of defaults and decide, in writing, which ones you

keep. A template written for a different state cannot do that job, because it is

arguing with a statute you are not subject to.

The clause that fails first is money out

If I get one clause in an agreement, I take the tax distribution clause.

Here is why. A pass-through entity allocates income to its members whether or not

it distributes cash. In April, each member's K-1 shows a share of the profit, and

each member owes tax on it personally. The company does not owe that tax. The

member does.

Take a two member LLC that earns 300,000 dollars in a year and puts every dollar

of it into inventory for the spring. Each member's K-1 shows 150,000 dollars of

income. Neither member received anything. Both have a tax bill on income they

never touched, and one of them may not have the cash to pay it. That is phantom

income, and it does not require anyone to behave badly. It just requires an

agreement that never said the company must release enough cash to cover the tax

on what it allocated.

The clause itself is short. It sets a formula, usually an assumed tax rate

applied to the income allocated to each member, and it requires the company to

distribute at least that much by a stated date ahead of the filing deadline. Then

it treats the tax distribution as an advance against future distributions, so

nobody comes out ahead.

Around it sit three other money clauses templates tend to skip. Who decides

whether there is a distribution at all, and by what vote. Whether money a member

puts in later is a capital contribution, which changes ownership percentages, or a

loan, which gets repaid with interest and does not. And what happens when the

company needs money and one member will not or cannot put it in, which is the

capital call question. Without a stated consequence, a capital call is a request.

With one, the non-contributing member's ownership is diluted by a formula both of

them signed while they still liked each other.

Who can sign what

Every LLC is either member-managed or manager-managed, and the difference decides

who can bind the company to a contract. Outsiders rely on it. A bank asks for the

agreement precisely to find out whether the person in front of them has the

authority to sign the note.

Most templates check the box and stop. What they leave out is the list of acts

that need more than one signature no matter who is managing. Borrowing above a

stated amount. Pledging company assets. Signing a lease past a stated term.

Selling or buying real property. Hiring or firing at the level that changes the

business. Admitting a new member. Entering a contract with an entity one of the

owners also owns. Filing for bankruptcy. Changing the tax election.

Write that list with dollar thresholds and required votes, and two things happen.

Internally, nobody has to guess. Externally, you have a document that answers the

lender's authority question in one page instead of a phone call.

While you are there, say something about duties. Most modern LLC acts let the

agreement narrow the fiduciary duties members owe each other, within limits, and

most will not let you eliminate the duty of good faith and fair dealing. If one

member runs a second business in the same trade, the agreement should say so and

say whether that is permitted. Otherwise the duty of loyalty says it is not, and

you have built a lawsuit into the founding documents.

Getting out, being pushed out, and dying

The clauses owners most regret skipping are the exit clauses, because by the time

you need them the parties are not cooperating.

A complete exit section answers a specific set of questions. Can a member sell to

an outsider, and does the company or the other members get first refusal. What

happens on death, and does the interest pass to a spouse who now sits in

meetings. What happens on divorce, when a court may be dividing marital property

that includes the interest. What happens if a member becomes disabled and stops

working but keeps owning. Can a member be expelled, on what grounds, and who

votes. And when an interest does change hands, how is it valued.

That last one is where the template goes quiet, and a valuation clause that says

"fair market value" without a method is a clause that says "hire two appraisers

and litigate." Pick something concrete. A formula tied to a multiple of earnings.

An annually updated value the members agree to in writing. A named appraisal

process with a tiebreak. Then say how it gets paid, because a buyout that must be

funded in cash on day one will kill the company that has to fund it. A note over

several years with stated interest is usually the survivable answer.

Then the deadlock clause. Two owners at 50 percent each, disagreeing, with no

mechanism, is a dissolution petition. The agreement can supply a tiebreaker: a

named third party, a mandatory mediation step, or a buy-sell trigger where one

member names a price and the other chooses which side of it to take.

What a reader outside the company checks

Your agreement will be read by people who did not sign it. A bank before a loan.

A title company before a closing. A buyer's lawyer in diligence. A landlord. An

insurer. Sometimes a judge.

They are all checking the same short list. Who owns what percentage, and does it

add up. Who is authorized to sign this specific document. Has anything been

amended, and is there a clean record of the amendments. Do the ownership

percentages in the agreement match the K-1s, the bank signature card, and the

annual report. That last check catches more problems than anything else, because

companies change their ownership in conversation and never change it on paper.

An agreement that is internally consistent, signed by every owner and backed by

tax returns that say the same thing is worth more than a longer one contradicted

by its own filings. If yours has been in a drawer since formation, the useful

first move is not a rewrite. It is reading the ownership section out loud and

checking whether it still describes the company you are running.

Common questions

does an llc really need an operating agreement

Most states do not require one to form the company, but the state's LLC act supplies default rules that govern anything your agreement leaves out. Those defaults cover voting, allocations, transfers and dissolution, and they often do not match what the owners assume. Banks, title companies and buyers also ask to see the agreement before they will proceed.

what is a tax distribution clause

It requires the company to distribute enough cash for members to pay the tax on income the company allocated to them, whether or not it distributed anything else. Pass-through income is taxed to the members personally even when the cash stayed in the business. The clause usually applies an assumed rate to allocated income and treats the payment as an advance against later distributions.

can i use a free operating agreement template

A template gives you the structural sections, but it will not resolve the choices your state's statute leaves open, and it will not price a buyout or break a deadlock. The parts that matter under pressure are the money clauses, the authority limits and the exit terms. Treat a template as a starting outline rather than a finished contract.

More on this